Charlie Hebdo Muhammad Cartoon Translated. Charlie hebdo has responded in its latest issue by republishing a dozen of the mocking drawings which depict the prophet. Luz went on to say that the cover is a callback to the 2011 cover that provoked other terrorists to firebomb charlie hebdo's offices: The french council for the muslim faith eventually sued the weekly for the cartoon. Satirical paper charlie hebdo reruns muhammad cartoons as 14 go on trial for paris attacks. September 2, 2020 / 2:58 pm / cbs news 7, 2015, the french satirical magazine was targeted by two islamic extremists over a cartoon drawing of the prophet muhammad, which the magazine had published in 2006. By elaine cobbe updated on: The issue has since been considered the one which positioned charlie hebdo as a target for terrorist attacks. Within its pages, the magazine published 12 cartoons of the prophet muhammad, bringing unprecedented condemnation from the muslim world. A drawing of mohammed saying, 100 lashes if you don't. Published in october 2014, this controversial charlie hebdo cover depicts an isis man moments before he beheads muhammad. In the comic, muhammad says, i am the prophet, you idiot, to which the isis insurgent exclaims, shut your face, infidel. the graphic cover follows the isis beheadings of three americans. Charlie hebdo this section of the mohammed image archive features an extensive collection of mohammed cartoons that have appeared in the pages of the french humor publication charlie hebdo.it also compiles editorial cartoons (featuring mohammed) about charlie hebdo which appeared in other outlets. The real reasons cartoons of mohammed offend so many muslims charlie hebdo's most famous cartoons, translated and explained major russian tv network says us intelligence carried out the charlie. When the magazine refused, the french.
Charlie Hebdo Muhammad Cartoon Translated - When The Magazine Refused, The French.
Post Attack Charlie Hebdo Cover Uses Prophet Cartoon. By elaine cobbe updated on: Within its pages, the magazine published 12 cartoons of the prophet muhammad, bringing unprecedented condemnation from the muslim world. Satirical paper charlie hebdo reruns muhammad cartoons as 14 go on trial for paris attacks. A drawing of mohammed saying, 100 lashes if you don't. The real reasons cartoons of mohammed offend so many muslims charlie hebdo's most famous cartoons, translated and explained major russian tv network says us intelligence carried out the charlie. Luz went on to say that the cover is a callback to the 2011 cover that provoked other terrorists to firebomb charlie hebdo's offices: When the magazine refused, the french. Charlie hebdo has responded in its latest issue by republishing a dozen of the mocking drawings which depict the prophet. The french council for the muslim faith eventually sued the weekly for the cartoon. Published in october 2014, this controversial charlie hebdo cover depicts an isis man moments before he beheads muhammad. 7, 2015, the french satirical magazine was targeted by two islamic extremists over a cartoon drawing of the prophet muhammad, which the magazine had published in 2006. September 2, 2020 / 2:58 pm / cbs news The issue has since been considered the one which positioned charlie hebdo as a target for terrorist attacks. In the comic, muhammad says, i am the prophet, you idiot, to which the isis insurgent exclaims, shut your face, infidel. the graphic cover follows the isis beheadings of three americans. Charlie hebdo this section of the mohammed image archive features an extensive collection of mohammed cartoons that have appeared in the pages of the french humor publication charlie hebdo.it also compiles editorial cartoons (featuring mohammed) about charlie hebdo which appeared in other outlets.
These drawings are now part of history, and you can't rewrite history, any more than you can erase it.
Charlie hebdo republishes prophet muhammad cartoons as trial begins saphora smith and nancy ing 9/2/2020 u.s. Thousands protest reprinting of charlie hebdo prophet muhammad cartoons in lahore. Charlie hebdo is a satirical politically incorrect french newspaper founded in 1970. Including the famous one from charlie hebdo showing muhammad in tears, annoyed at being loved by idiots. Breaks daily record for coronavirus cases with nearly 84,000 new infections 25 attack, in which a man with a meat cleaver injured two people outside the headquarters of satirical magazine charlie hebdo; Charlie hebdo republishes prophet muhammad cartoons as trial begins saphora smith and nancy ing 9/2/2020 u.s. Charlie hebdo has responded in its latest issue by republishing a dozen of the mocking drawings which depict the prophet. The image has fuelled the row between the two countries after french president emmanuel macron defended the right to show cartoons of the prophet mohammed. Within its pages, the magazine published 12 cartoons of the prophet muhammad, bringing unprecedented condemnation from the muslim world. Before dawn in paris on wednesday morning, and all over france, newsstands were overwhelmed with demand for the latest edition of charlie hebdo, the survivors' issue.it sold out within minutes. It was the publication of these drawings, considered blasphemy by a number of muslims, which was the motive for the january 7 massacre by assassins who wanted to, as they shouted on leaving from the premises of charlie hebdo , avenge the prophet… Radical islamic terrorists massacred 12 people in paris at the offices of the satirical charlie hebdo magazine in 2015, including a police protection officer and a building maintenance workers, over its publication of unflattering cartoons of the islamic prophet. Cartoons from the french satirical weekly newspaper charlie hebdo were projected on the facades of buildings across france to mark a national day of mourning in honor of slain teacher samuel paty. The cartoons that led to the teacher's death were the same drawings that were at the center of a deadly 2015 extremist attack on charlie hebdo's staff. The latest issue from the satirical magazine included cartoon images of various people's occupations with decapitated. The french satirical magazine charlie hebdo republished controversial caricatures of the prophet muhammad on wednesday to mark the start of a trial more than five years after its offices were attacked by islamist gunmen. Published in october 2014, this controversial charlie hebdo cover depicts an isis man moments before he beheads muhammad. The real reasons cartoons of mohammed offend so many muslims charlie hebdo's most famous cartoons, translated and explained major russian tv network says us intelligence carried out the charlie. To prevent the sessions from getting out of hand, the teacher chose not to show the cartoons, but rather to describe them in words. The magazine accused erdoğan of sowing the seeds. When the magazine refused, the french. By elaine cobbe updated on: Luz went on to say that the cover is a callback to the 2011 cover that provoked other terrorists to firebomb charlie hebdo's offices: French satirical magazine charlie hebdo was condemned by turkish officials for mocking turkish president tayyip erdoğan in a political cartoon. As previously reported, paty was decapitated last friday after showing his class caricatures of the prophet muhammad from the charlie hebdo magazine in 2015 in a discussion about freedom of speech. The attackers who stormed the magazine's paris offices and a kosher supermarket killing 17 people in january 2015, including 12 of the magazine's staff, are dead but their. In 2006, the magazine was unsuccessfully sued by muslim organizations for. In the comic, muhammad says, i am the prophet, you idiot, to which the isis insurgent exclaims, shut your face, infidel. the graphic cover follows the isis beheadings of three americans. Charlie hebdo this section of the mohammed image archive features an extensive collection of mohammed cartoons that have appeared in the pages of the french humor publication charlie hebdo.it also compiles editorial cartoons (featuring mohammed) about charlie hebdo which appeared in other outlets. From the 2000s onward, its criticism of islam in particular has drawn significant attention:
Cartoonists React To Attack On Charlie Hebdo Cgtn America : It Was The Publication Of These Drawings, Considered Blasphemy By A Number Of Muslims, Which Was The Motive For The January 7 Massacre By Assassins Who Wanted To, As They Shouted On Leaving From The Premises Of Charlie Hebdo , Avenge The Prophet…
What Charlie Hebdo Taught Me About Freedom Of Speech Los Angeles Review Of Books. Published in october 2014, this controversial charlie hebdo cover depicts an isis man moments before he beheads muhammad. A drawing of mohammed saying, 100 lashes if you don't. September 2, 2020 / 2:58 pm / cbs news Luz went on to say that the cover is a callback to the 2011 cover that provoked other terrorists to firebomb charlie hebdo's offices: The issue has since been considered the one which positioned charlie hebdo as a target for terrorist attacks. 7, 2015, the french satirical magazine was targeted by two islamic extremists over a cartoon drawing of the prophet muhammad, which the magazine had published in 2006. The real reasons cartoons of mohammed offend so many muslims charlie hebdo's most famous cartoons, translated and explained major russian tv network says us intelligence carried out the charlie. By elaine cobbe updated on: Charlie hebdo has responded in its latest issue by republishing a dozen of the mocking drawings which depict the prophet. In the comic, muhammad says, i am the prophet, you idiot, to which the isis insurgent exclaims, shut your face, infidel. the graphic cover follows the isis beheadings of three americans. When the magazine refused, the french. The french council for the muslim faith eventually sued the weekly for the cartoon. Within its pages, the magazine published 12 cartoons of the prophet muhammad, bringing unprecedented condemnation from the muslim world. Satirical paper charlie hebdo reruns muhammad cartoons as 14 go on trial for paris attacks. Charlie hebdo this section of the mohammed image archive features an extensive collection of mohammed cartoons that have appeared in the pages of the french humor publication charlie hebdo.it also compiles editorial cartoons (featuring mohammed) about charlie hebdo which appeared in other outlets.
What Should Everyone Know About Charlie Hebdo Quora . To Prevent The Sessions From Getting Out Of Hand, The Teacher Chose Not To Show The Cartoons, But Rather To Describe Them In Words.
Here S Why Charlie Hebdo Cartoonist Luz Drew Muhammad Crying For The Cover The San Diego Union Tribune. Within its pages, the magazine published 12 cartoons of the prophet muhammad, bringing unprecedented condemnation from the muslim world. The french council for the muslim faith eventually sued the weekly for the cartoon. The real reasons cartoons of mohammed offend so many muslims charlie hebdo's most famous cartoons, translated and explained major russian tv network says us intelligence carried out the charlie. In the comic, muhammad says, i am the prophet, you idiot, to which the isis insurgent exclaims, shut your face, infidel. the graphic cover follows the isis beheadings of three americans. A drawing of mohammed saying, 100 lashes if you don't. Published in october 2014, this controversial charlie hebdo cover depicts an isis man moments before he beheads muhammad. By elaine cobbe updated on: Charlie hebdo has responded in its latest issue by republishing a dozen of the mocking drawings which depict the prophet. Luz went on to say that the cover is a callback to the 2011 cover that provoked other terrorists to firebomb charlie hebdo's offices: 7, 2015, the french satirical magazine was targeted by two islamic extremists over a cartoon drawing of the prophet muhammad, which the magazine had published in 2006.
These Are The Charlie Hebdo Cartoons That Terrorists Thought Were Worth Killing Over Huffpost . These drawings are now part of history, and you can't rewrite history, any more than you can erase it.
Charlie Hebdo Puts Mohammed On Its New Cover Houston Style Magazine Urban Weekly Newspaper Publication Website. Luz went on to say that the cover is a callback to the 2011 cover that provoked other terrorists to firebomb charlie hebdo's offices: The issue has since been considered the one which positioned charlie hebdo as a target for terrorist attacks. Published in october 2014, this controversial charlie hebdo cover depicts an isis man moments before he beheads muhammad. By elaine cobbe updated on: Charlie hebdo has responded in its latest issue by republishing a dozen of the mocking drawings which depict the prophet. Satirical paper charlie hebdo reruns muhammad cartoons as 14 go on trial for paris attacks. The french council for the muslim faith eventually sued the weekly for the cartoon. Charlie hebdo this section of the mohammed image archive features an extensive collection of mohammed cartoons that have appeared in the pages of the french humor publication charlie hebdo.it also compiles editorial cartoons (featuring mohammed) about charlie hebdo which appeared in other outlets. A drawing of mohammed saying, 100 lashes if you don't. The real reasons cartoons of mohammed offend so many muslims charlie hebdo's most famous cartoons, translated and explained major russian tv network says us intelligence carried out the charlie. 7, 2015, the french satirical magazine was targeted by two islamic extremists over a cartoon drawing of the prophet muhammad, which the magazine had published in 2006. September 2, 2020 / 2:58 pm / cbs news Within its pages, the magazine published 12 cartoons of the prophet muhammad, bringing unprecedented condemnation from the muslim world. In the comic, muhammad says, i am the prophet, you idiot, to which the isis insurgent exclaims, shut your face, infidel. the graphic cover follows the isis beheadings of three americans. When the magazine refused, the french.
Charlie Hebdo In English Je Suis Charlie Understanding Charlie Hebdo Cartoons Kindle Edition By Choice Vlad Humor Entertainment Kindle Ebooks Amazon Com . The Latest Issue From The Satirical Magazine Included Cartoon Images Of Various People's Occupations With Decapitated.
10 Incendiary Moments In The History Of Charlie Hebdo Listverse. Charlie hebdo this section of the mohammed image archive features an extensive collection of mohammed cartoons that have appeared in the pages of the french humor publication charlie hebdo.it also compiles editorial cartoons (featuring mohammed) about charlie hebdo which appeared in other outlets. September 2, 2020 / 2:58 pm / cbs news By elaine cobbe updated on: The issue has since been considered the one which positioned charlie hebdo as a target for terrorist attacks. When the magazine refused, the french. Luz went on to say that the cover is a callback to the 2011 cover that provoked other terrorists to firebomb charlie hebdo's offices: In the comic, muhammad says, i am the prophet, you idiot, to which the isis insurgent exclaims, shut your face, infidel. the graphic cover follows the isis beheadings of three americans. Satirical paper charlie hebdo reruns muhammad cartoons as 14 go on trial for paris attacks. Charlie hebdo has responded in its latest issue by republishing a dozen of the mocking drawings which depict the prophet. 7, 2015, the french satirical magazine was targeted by two islamic extremists over a cartoon drawing of the prophet muhammad, which the magazine had published in 2006. Within its pages, the magazine published 12 cartoons of the prophet muhammad, bringing unprecedented condemnation from the muslim world. The french council for the muslim faith eventually sued the weekly for the cartoon. A drawing of mohammed saying, 100 lashes if you don't. The real reasons cartoons of mohammed offend so many muslims charlie hebdo's most famous cartoons, translated and explained major russian tv network says us intelligence carried out the charlie. Published in october 2014, this controversial charlie hebdo cover depicts an isis man moments before he beheads muhammad.
Historic Charlie Hebdo , French For Charlie Weekly) Is A French Satirical Weekly Magazine, Featuring Cartoons, Reports, Polemics, And Jokes.
Mohammed Image Archive Charlie Hebdo. In the comic, muhammad says, i am the prophet, you idiot, to which the isis insurgent exclaims, shut your face, infidel. the graphic cover follows the isis beheadings of three americans. Published in october 2014, this controversial charlie hebdo cover depicts an isis man moments before he beheads muhammad. The french council for the muslim faith eventually sued the weekly for the cartoon. 7, 2015, the french satirical magazine was targeted by two islamic extremists over a cartoon drawing of the prophet muhammad, which the magazine had published in 2006. September 2, 2020 / 2:58 pm / cbs news The issue has since been considered the one which positioned charlie hebdo as a target for terrorist attacks. Charlie hebdo this section of the mohammed image archive features an extensive collection of mohammed cartoons that have appeared in the pages of the french humor publication charlie hebdo.it also compiles editorial cartoons (featuring mohammed) about charlie hebdo which appeared in other outlets. A drawing of mohammed saying, 100 lashes if you don't. By elaine cobbe updated on: Luz went on to say that the cover is a callback to the 2011 cover that provoked other terrorists to firebomb charlie hebdo's offices: Charlie hebdo has responded in its latest issue by republishing a dozen of the mocking drawings which depict the prophet. The real reasons cartoons of mohammed offend so many muslims charlie hebdo's most famous cartoons, translated and explained major russian tv network says us intelligence carried out the charlie. Satirical paper charlie hebdo reruns muhammad cartoons as 14 go on trial for paris attacks. When the magazine refused, the french. Within its pages, the magazine published 12 cartoons of the prophet muhammad, bringing unprecedented condemnation from the muslim world.
In Defence Of Charlie Hebdo Open Letter To An American Friend Sam Sholli . The Cartoons That Led To The Teacher's Death Were The Same Drawings That Were At The Center Of A Deadly 2015 Extremist Attack On Charlie Hebdo's Staff.
Charlie Hebdo To Reprint Muhammad Cartoons As Trial Linked To 2015 Attack Begins Npr. When the magazine refused, the french. Charlie hebdo has responded in its latest issue by republishing a dozen of the mocking drawings which depict the prophet. Published in october 2014, this controversial charlie hebdo cover depicts an isis man moments before he beheads muhammad. The issue has since been considered the one which positioned charlie hebdo as a target for terrorist attacks. Within its pages, the magazine published 12 cartoons of the prophet muhammad, bringing unprecedented condemnation from the muslim world. Charlie hebdo this section of the mohammed image archive features an extensive collection of mohammed cartoons that have appeared in the pages of the french humor publication charlie hebdo.it also compiles editorial cartoons (featuring mohammed) about charlie hebdo which appeared in other outlets. A drawing of mohammed saying, 100 lashes if you don't. Satirical paper charlie hebdo reruns muhammad cartoons as 14 go on trial for paris attacks. September 2, 2020 / 2:58 pm / cbs news In the comic, muhammad says, i am the prophet, you idiot, to which the isis insurgent exclaims, shut your face, infidel. the graphic cover follows the isis beheadings of three americans. 7, 2015, the french satirical magazine was targeted by two islamic extremists over a cartoon drawing of the prophet muhammad, which the magazine had published in 2006. The real reasons cartoons of mohammed offend so many muslims charlie hebdo's most famous cartoons, translated and explained major russian tv network says us intelligence carried out the charlie. The french council for the muslim faith eventually sued the weekly for the cartoon. Luz went on to say that the cover is a callback to the 2011 cover that provoked other terrorists to firebomb charlie hebdo's offices: By elaine cobbe updated on:
Cartoonists React To Attack On Charlie Hebdo Cgtn America . Charlie Hebdo Republishes Prophet Muhammad Cartoons As Trial Begins Saphora Smith And Nancy Ing 9/2/2020 U.s.
Charlie Hebdo S Most Famous Cartoons Translated And Explained Youtube. When the magazine refused, the french. Satirical paper charlie hebdo reruns muhammad cartoons as 14 go on trial for paris attacks. 7, 2015, the french satirical magazine was targeted by two islamic extremists over a cartoon drawing of the prophet muhammad, which the magazine had published in 2006. Charlie hebdo has responded in its latest issue by republishing a dozen of the mocking drawings which depict the prophet. Published in october 2014, this controversial charlie hebdo cover depicts an isis man moments before he beheads muhammad. Charlie hebdo this section of the mohammed image archive features an extensive collection of mohammed cartoons that have appeared in the pages of the french humor publication charlie hebdo.it also compiles editorial cartoons (featuring mohammed) about charlie hebdo which appeared in other outlets. Within its pages, the magazine published 12 cartoons of the prophet muhammad, bringing unprecedented condemnation from the muslim world. By elaine cobbe updated on: A drawing of mohammed saying, 100 lashes if you don't. The issue has since been considered the one which positioned charlie hebdo as a target for terrorist attacks. The french council for the muslim faith eventually sued the weekly for the cartoon. September 2, 2020 / 2:58 pm / cbs news The real reasons cartoons of mohammed offend so many muslims charlie hebdo's most famous cartoons, translated and explained major russian tv network says us intelligence carried out the charlie. Luz went on to say that the cover is a callback to the 2011 cover that provoked other terrorists to firebomb charlie hebdo's offices: In the comic, muhammad says, i am the prophet, you idiot, to which the isis insurgent exclaims, shut your face, infidel. the graphic cover follows the isis beheadings of three americans.
Charlie Hebdo Draws Ire With Barcelona Attack Cartoon News Al Jazeera , The Real Reasons Cartoons Of Mohammed Offend So Many Muslims Charlie Hebdo's Most Famous Cartoons, Translated And Explained Major Russian Tv Network Says Us Intelligence Carried Out The Charlie.
Iran Politics Club Forum View Topic Life Of Muhammad Cartoons Charlie Hebdo In English. Luz went on to say that the cover is a callback to the 2011 cover that provoked other terrorists to firebomb charlie hebdo's offices: September 2, 2020 / 2:58 pm / cbs news In the comic, muhammad says, i am the prophet, you idiot, to which the isis insurgent exclaims, shut your face, infidel. the graphic cover follows the isis beheadings of three americans. When the magazine refused, the french. 7, 2015, the french satirical magazine was targeted by two islamic extremists over a cartoon drawing of the prophet muhammad, which the magazine had published in 2006. Within its pages, the magazine published 12 cartoons of the prophet muhammad, bringing unprecedented condemnation from the muslim world. Charlie hebdo this section of the mohammed image archive features an extensive collection of mohammed cartoons that have appeared in the pages of the french humor publication charlie hebdo.it also compiles editorial cartoons (featuring mohammed) about charlie hebdo which appeared in other outlets. Charlie hebdo has responded in its latest issue by republishing a dozen of the mocking drawings which depict the prophet. By elaine cobbe updated on: The issue has since been considered the one which positioned charlie hebdo as a target for terrorist attacks. The real reasons cartoons of mohammed offend so many muslims charlie hebdo's most famous cartoons, translated and explained major russian tv network says us intelligence carried out the charlie. The french council for the muslim faith eventually sued the weekly for the cartoon. A drawing of mohammed saying, 100 lashes if you don't. Published in october 2014, this controversial charlie hebdo cover depicts an isis man moments before he beheads muhammad. Satirical paper charlie hebdo reruns muhammad cartoons as 14 go on trial for paris attacks.
Iran Politics Club Forum View Topic Life Of Muhammad Cartoons Charlie Hebdo In English - The Magazine Accused Erdoğan Of Sowing The Seeds.
The Assassin Is Still Out There Charlie Hebdo Provocative Anniversary Cover Business Insider. Charlie hebdo this section of the mohammed image archive features an extensive collection of mohammed cartoons that have appeared in the pages of the french humor publication charlie hebdo.it also compiles editorial cartoons (featuring mohammed) about charlie hebdo which appeared in other outlets. Within its pages, the magazine published 12 cartoons of the prophet muhammad, bringing unprecedented condemnation from the muslim world. Published in october 2014, this controversial charlie hebdo cover depicts an isis man moments before he beheads muhammad. The real reasons cartoons of mohammed offend so many muslims charlie hebdo's most famous cartoons, translated and explained major russian tv network says us intelligence carried out the charlie. When the magazine refused, the french. The issue has since been considered the one which positioned charlie hebdo as a target for terrorist attacks. 7, 2015, the french satirical magazine was targeted by two islamic extremists over a cartoon drawing of the prophet muhammad, which the magazine had published in 2006. In the comic, muhammad says, i am the prophet, you idiot, to which the isis insurgent exclaims, shut your face, infidel. the graphic cover follows the isis beheadings of three americans. Satirical paper charlie hebdo reruns muhammad cartoons as 14 go on trial for paris attacks. September 2, 2020 / 2:58 pm / cbs news A drawing of mohammed saying, 100 lashes if you don't. Luz went on to say that the cover is a callback to the 2011 cover that provoked other terrorists to firebomb charlie hebdo's offices: Charlie hebdo has responded in its latest issue by republishing a dozen of the mocking drawings which depict the prophet. The french council for the muslim faith eventually sued the weekly for the cartoon. By elaine cobbe updated on:
Why Charlie Hebdo S Cartoons Of The Drowned Syrian Boy Are Lost In Translation : French Satirical Magazine Charlie Hebdo Was Condemned By Turkish Officials For Mocking Turkish President Tayyip Erdoğan In A Political Cartoon.
Charlie Hebdo Republishes Muhammad Cartoon Ahead Of Shooting Trial The Washington Post. Charlie hebdo has responded in its latest issue by republishing a dozen of the mocking drawings which depict the prophet. A drawing of mohammed saying, 100 lashes if you don't. Within its pages, the magazine published 12 cartoons of the prophet muhammad, bringing unprecedented condemnation from the muslim world. When the magazine refused, the french. The french council for the muslim faith eventually sued the weekly for the cartoon. Published in october 2014, this controversial charlie hebdo cover depicts an isis man moments before he beheads muhammad. Satirical paper charlie hebdo reruns muhammad cartoons as 14 go on trial for paris attacks. Charlie hebdo this section of the mohammed image archive features an extensive collection of mohammed cartoons that have appeared in the pages of the french humor publication charlie hebdo.it also compiles editorial cartoons (featuring mohammed) about charlie hebdo which appeared in other outlets. The issue has since been considered the one which positioned charlie hebdo as a target for terrorist attacks. By elaine cobbe updated on: September 2, 2020 / 2:58 pm / cbs news In the comic, muhammad says, i am the prophet, you idiot, to which the isis insurgent exclaims, shut your face, infidel. the graphic cover follows the isis beheadings of three americans. Luz went on to say that the cover is a callback to the 2011 cover that provoked other terrorists to firebomb charlie hebdo's offices: 7, 2015, the french satirical magazine was targeted by two islamic extremists over a cartoon drawing of the prophet muhammad, which the magazine had published in 2006. The real reasons cartoons of mohammed offend so many muslims charlie hebdo's most famous cartoons, translated and explained major russian tv network says us intelligence carried out the charlie.